Abdoul Anziz Said Attoumane
The cluster concept is applied to Small Island Developing States (SIDS) through models developed and tested in continental settings. These are generally Marshall’s industrial district, Porter’s competitive cluster and Schmitz’s collective efficiency. To varying degrees, these models depend on a critical mass of firms, sufficient spatial density and a deep domestic market. Small SIDS, however, fail to meet all three conditions at once. Following Martin and Sunley (2003) and Hamdouch (2008), the article assesses the relevance, usefulness and limits of these models for small island economies. It confronts them with the stylised facts of a corpus of island productive agglomerations and treats Singapore as a limiting case. Neither Marshallian passive externalities nor Porterian domestic rivalry appear as triggers. Schmitz’s model proves the most transferable, subject to three amendments. Joint action substitutes for missing external economies, the capital anchoring of a pivotal firm may replace it, and insertion into value chains acts as a trigger as much as a discipline. The article proposes an agenda built on four shifts. They lead from density to anchoring, from domestic to imported rivalry, from passive externalities to institutionalised joint action and from the subnational cluster to the countrycluster. It suggests testing them through qualitative comparative analysis, network analysis and process tracing.
Clusters, Small Island Developing States, Industrial Districts, Porter’s Diamond, Collective Efficiency, Small-State Economics, Territorial Anchoring
Abdoul Anziz Said Attoumane*, Economist, EUCLID University, Banjul, The Gambia, PhD candidate in Sustainable Development and Diplomacy, Comores.
Said Attoumane, A. A. (2026). Cluster Models Confronted with Small Island Developing States: Relevance, Usefulness and Limits of the Marshall, Porter and Schmitz Models. Econ Dev Glob Mark, 2(2), 01-25.